The Political Breakdown: American Politics
Are you frustrated with political games and media spin? Is It Allgood Politics, led by Avee Allgood, digs deep into political issues to uncover the truth behind media narratives, expose hidden agendas, and show where we can come together. Insulting voters or dismissing their beliefs only deepens the divide and erodes trust. Instead, my goal is to offer a space where all perspectives are examined and all voices are valued, creating an informed citizenry empowered to make their own choices. Importantly, our work is NOT about advocating for one side or party. It’s about equipping you—the voter—with the tools and knowledge to form your own opinions. Thus, I am NOT here to tell you which policies are best for you or who to vote for; I am here to hold politicians accountable, uncover the full picture, and foster a political culture rooted in fairness and respect. WE DON’T PROMOTE OR FOCUS ON ANY SINGLE PARTY!As a reminder, Avee Allgood offers rigorously researched insights that encourages critical thinking and objectivity. Our analysis covers a wide range of political perspectives to help readers understand the complexities of political discourse without aligning with any specific party or ideology. Categories
All
|
To keep our work going and improve our services, please consider subscribing or supporting via a one-time donation. |
Remember: THe goal isn't to win the argument but to find agreement by looking at the issue in new ways
THE LANDSCAPE OF AMERICAN CIVIL LIBERTIES IS EXPERIENCING PROFOUND SHIFTS AS RECENT JUDICIAL DECISIONS CHALLENGE THE ESTABLISHED NORMS OF ABORTION RIGHTS AND THE RIGHT TO PROTEST. THIS ARTICLE EXPLORES THESE PRESSING ISSUES, FOCUSING ON SIGNIFICANT COURT RULINGS IN ARIZONA AND ACROSS SEVERAL STATES AFFECTING PROTEST LAWS, EXAMINING THE BROADER IMPLICATIONS FOR CIVIL LIBERTIES IN THE UNITED STATES.
HERE, I URGE YOU, THE READER, TO ENGAGE THOUGHTFULLY AND EMPATHETICALLY IN THIS DISCUSSION, AIMING NOT TO WIN AN ARGUMENT BUT TO FIND COMMON GROUND AND MUTUAL RESPECT. AS A RESULT, I ASK YOU TO APPROACH THE ABORTION DEBATE WITH A READINESS TO LISTEN AND LEARN, RATHER THAN SIMPLY TO RESPOND. DESPITE THE APPARENT DIVIDES, THERE ARE COMMON VALUES THAT MANY SHARE, SUCH AS RESPECT FOR LIFE AND PERSONAL FREEDOM. THESE VALUES WILL BE EXPLORED AIMING TO BUILD A FOUNDATION FOR CONSTRUCTIVE DIALOGUE THAT ALLOWS FOR BETTER UNDERSTANDING OF THE BROADER IMPACTS OF THESE DECISIONS. THUS, LET US MOVE FORWARD NOT AS ADVERSARIES BUT AS FELLOW CITIZENS COMMITTED TO UPHOLDING THE DIGNITY AND RIGHTS OF ALL INDIVIDUALS. TOGETHER, WE CAN FOSTER A MORE EMPATHETIC, INFORMED, AND RESPECTFUL DISCOURSE.
PART 1: ABORTION & Divorce
IN THE UNITED STATES, THE PRINCIPLE OF SEPARATION OF CHURCH AND STATE IS NOT JUST A CORNERSTONE OF DEMOCRACY, BUT A FUNDAMENTAL ELEMENT OF FREEDOM ENSHRINED WITHIN THE FIRST AMENDMENT OF OUR CONSTITUTION. THIS GUARANTEES INDIVIDUALS THE FREEDOM TO FOLLOW OR REJECT ANY RELIGIOUS BELIEFS. HOWEVER, AS WE STAND HERE TODAY, THIS CHERISHED PRINCIPLE IS UNDER THREAT, CAUGHT IN THE CROSSFIRE OF A DEBATE THAT RAGES ACROSS THE HEART OF AMERICA - THE ABORTION DEBATE.
DISCLAIMER: THIS ANALYSIS EXPLORES THE ARGUMENTS FROM BOTH PRO-ABORTION AND ANTI-ABORTION ADVOCATES, TRACING THE HISTORICAL ROOTS OF THE DEBATE AND IDENTIFYING POTENTIAL AREAS OF CONVERGENCE BETWEEN THESE OPPOSING VIEWS. IMPORTANTLY, THE ABORTION DEBATE EXTENDS BEYOND THE ISSUE ITSELF, TOUCHING ON BROADER CONSTITUTIONAL IMPLICATIONS. FOR NAVIGATING PURPOSES, PLEASE NOTE THAT THE ANTI-ABORTION PERSPECTIVE DISCUSSION SECTION FOLLOWS THE SECTION TITLED, 'HOW HAS ABORTION POLICY CHANGED IN THE USA OVER THE YEARS?'. **ALTHOUGH I RECOMMEND READING THE FULL ANALYSIS FOR A COMPREHENSIVE UNDERSTANDING, FEEL FREE TO SKIM OVER SECTIONS OF THE ANALYSIS BASED ON THE SECTION TITLES TO FIND THE MOST RELEVANT CONTENT FOR YOU.
FIRST, IN ADDRESSING THE RESURGENCE OF STRINGENT ABORTION LAWS, PARTICULARLY EXEMPLIFIED BY ARIZONA'S REINSTATEMENT OF ITS PRE-STATEHOOD BAN, WE CONFRONT A COMPLEX INTERSECTION OF MORALITY, LAW, AND INDIVIDUAL RIGHTS. THIS ISSUE, DEEPLY DIVISIVE AND OFTEN ALIGNED WITH PARTISAN LINES, INVITES A NUANCED DISCUSSION BEYOND MERE POLITICAL AFFILIATIONS, AIMING TO FOSTER UNDERSTANDING AND, IDEALLY, CONSENSUS ACROSS THE IDEOLOGICAL SPECTRUM.
BY OFFERING THIS ANALYSIS, I HOPE TO ILLUSTRATE HOW INGRAINED POLITICAL AND IDEOLOGICAL DIVISIONS CAN INFLUENCE PUBLIC POLICY. INDEED, THIS PHENOMENON, WHILE CENTERED ON THE ISSUE OF ABORTION, ACTUALLY REVEALS BROADER STRATEGIES EMPLOYED BY POLITICIANS TO CONSOLIDATE POWER, GALVANIZE THEIR BASE, AND SOMETIMES, INTENTIONALLY OR OTHERWISE, DIVIDE THE ELECTORATE. UNDERSTANDING WHY POLITICIANS MIGHT FOSTER OR EXPLOIT THESE DIVISIONS REQUIRES AN INVESTIGATION OF THEIR GOALS. REMEMBER, THE PROCESS BEHIND MOTIVATED REASONING IS NATURAL AND YOU ARE NOT AWARE YOU ARE DOING IT, SO YOU MUST ACTIVELY REMIND YOURSELF TO BE OPEN-MINDED AND LESS JUDGEMENTAL ON THE BASIS OF YOUR PERSONAL VIEWPOINTS. IT DOESN'T MATTER WHAT ONE PERSON THINKS, IT MATTERS WHAT IS BEST FOR THE MAJORITY OF AMERICANS.
POLITICIAN'S STRATEGY BEHIND USING THE ABORTION TOPIC
THE BIGGEST LIE BEING TOLD IS THE IDEA THAT NOBODY CAN CHANGE THEIR MIND ON ABORTION. THIS IS ABSOLUTELY UNTRUE. ON THE OTHER HAND, THE USE OF THIS HEATED RHETORIC, THAT AIMS TO TARGET EMOTIONS, AS A HOT TOPIC ISSUE, DOES IN FACT REFLECT A STRATEGY THAT POLITICIANS USE TO WIN AND MAINTAIN VOTERS, SO IT SEEMS AS THOUGH IT IS TRUE. ACCORDINGLY, THEY DO THIS BECAUSE IT IS EASY, AND THEY KNOW THAT IT HELPS MAINTAIN THEIR VOTERS, WHICH IS THE RELIGIOUS VOTERS IF REPUBLICAN, AND WOMEN VOTERS IF DEMOCRATIC. FOR INSTANCE, DEMOCRATS LOVE TO ACT LIKE THEY ARE THE CHAMPIONS OF PROTECTING ABORTIONS, AND SINCE 2022, IT SEEMS THIS IS THE ONLY THING THEY CAN TALK ABOUT. YET, AFTER DECADES OF BEING IN POWER, THEY HAVE NEVER ENSHRINED THIS RIGHT, LEAVING IT UP TO THE COURTS, THE ONE BRANCH OF GOVERNMENT THAT CITIZENS CANNOT CHOOSE WHO THEY ELECT. THUS, THEY LOVE TO RUN ON HOW REPUBLICANS STRIPPED THIS RIGHT AWAY, EFFECTIVELY TELLING VOTERS, I AM NOT POWERFUL ENOUGH TO PREVENT THIS, BUT IT'S THE OTHER GUYS FAULT, SO VOTE FOR ME SINCE I WOULDN'T HAVE DONE THAT. CONVERSELY, REPUBLICANS HAVE SUCCESSFULLY CAMPAIGNED ON THIS FOR YEARS AND NOW HAVE BEEN SUCCESSFUL IN THEIR GOAL, OVERTURNING A PRECEDENT THAT AT ONE TIME, WAS THOUGHT TO BE A GIVEN IN AMERICA DUE TO ITS STRONG PRECEDENT AND CONNECTION TO BILL OF RIGHTS LIBERTIES. HOWEVER, THOSE WHO TRUMPET THIS DECREASE AS A MORAL VICTORY MUST FACE THE HARSH REALITY THAT THE REDUCTION IN NUMBERS DOES NOT SIGNIFY FEWER ABORTIONS; IT SIGNALS MORE WOMEN DRIVEN TO DESPERATE MEASURES, MORE WOMEN DENIED ESSENTIAL HEALTHCARE, MORE WOMEN FACING THE DANGERS OF UNREGULATED PROCEDURES, AND A SOCIETY STEPPING BACKWARDS IN TERMS OF GENDER EQUALITY AND HUMAN RIGHTS. INDEED, MY GRANDMA TOLD ME THAT WHEN ABORTION WAS ILLEGAL PRE- ROE V WADE, WOMEN WOULD JUST USE A COAT HANGER TO ABORT THE CHILD, OR PURPOSEFULLY FALL DOWN THE STAIRS. THIS BRINGS FORTH THE QUESTION.... HOW DID WE GET HERE? TO BEST ANSWER THIS, AN OVERVIEW OF WHY THEY ARE DOING THIS IS NECESSARY, AS POLITICIANS ARE NOT WORKING IN OUR BEST INTEREST, ESPECIALLY AS PEOPLE PAY LESS ATTENTION TO WHAT THEY ARE ACTUALLY DOING / VOTING FOR IN CONGRESS. DESPITE THIS LACK OF ACCOUNTABILITY AND AWARENESS FROM VOTERS, WHEN THERE IS A NEW ELECTION, POLITICIANS NEED TO REMIND VOTERS OF WHY WE SHOULD VOTE FOR THEM. AS A RESULT, THEY OFTEN PICK AN ISSUE THAT DIVIDES US DUE TO THE FACT THEY ARE FUNDAMENTALLY AGAINST OUR VALUES, WHICH THUS MAKE IT EXTREMELY HARD TO EVER THINK ABOUT VOTING FOR THAT PARTY DUE TO THIS ISSUE- THIS IS CALLED IDENTITY POLITICS. MOREOVER, FEAR TACTICS ARE ALSO EMPLOYED, SUGGESTING THAT ELECTING THE OPPOSITION WOULD RESULT IN MORALLY REPREHENSIBLE OUTCOMES. FOR INSTANCE, IF YOU BELIEVE ABORTION IS MURDER, AND A CANDIDATE SUPPORTS MURDER, AND THIS ISSUE IS IMPORTANT TO YOU, NOTHING WILL CHANGE YOUR MIND AND MAKE YOU THINK ABOUT VOTING FOR OTHER CANDIDATES, EVEN THOSE WHO MAY BE MORE ALIGNED WITH EVERYTHING ELSE YOU WOULD WANT IN SOCIETY, EXCEPT THIS ISSUE. ACCORDINGLY, THIS "DIVIDE AND CONQUER" STRATEGY CAN BE EFFECTIVE FOR CONSOLIDATING A LOYAL VOTER BASE. BY EMPHASIZING AN ISSUE THAT EVOKES STRONG EMOTIONAL RESPONSES, SUCH AS FRAMING ABORTION AS MURDER, POLITICIANS CAN GALVANIZE A SEGMENT OF THE ELECTORATE. CONSEQUENTLY, THIS APPROACH OFTEN RESULTS IN A BINARY CHOICE FOR THE VOTERS: YOU ARE EITHER WITH US OR AGAINST US. UNFORTUNATELY, COMPLEX ISSUES ARE OFTEN SIMPLIFIED INTO THESE BINARY CHOICES. THIS REDUCTIONISM MAKES IT EASIER FOR POLITICIANS TO COMMUNICATE THEIR STANCES AND HARDER FOR VOTERS TO FIND COMMON GROUND ACROSS PARTY LINES. WHEN AN ISSUE LIKE ABORTION IS REDUCED TO A STARK MORAL CHOICE, IT OVERSHADOWS NUANCES AND MIDDLE GROUND THAT MIGHT EXIST. INDEED, WHEN VOTER ENGAGEMENT IS LOW, AND THERE IS A SIGNIFICANT GAP IN UNDERSTANDING THE FULL SCOPE OF WHAT POLITICIANS DO AND SUPPORT, IT BECOMES EASIER FOR POLITICIANS TO MANIPULATE OPINIONS WITH EMOTIONALLY CHARGED ISSUES. THUS, BY FOCUSING ON A CONTENTIOUS ISSUE LIKE ABORTION, POLITICIANS CAN POSITION THEMSELVES FIRMLY ON ONE SIDE OF A MORAL DIVIDE, APPEALING TO VOTERS WHO PRIORITIZE THAT ISSUE ABOVE OTHERS. THIS CAN BE A POWERFUL STRATEGY IN MAINTAINING VOTER LOYALTY, AS IT TAPS INTO FUNDAMENTAL VALUES AND BELIEFS THAT OFTEN GUIDE VOTER BEHAVIOR MORE STRONGLY THAN PRAGMATIC POLICY CONSIDERATIONS. CONSEQUENTLY, THIS STRATEGY CAN ERODE THE QUALITY OF DEMOCRATIC DIALOGUE. INSTEAD OF FOSTERING A CULTURE OF DEBATE AND COMPROMISE, POLITICS BECOMES ABOUT WINNING AT ALL COSTS. THE FOCUS SHIFTS FROM SOLVING SOCIETAL PROBLEMS TO SECURING VOTES THROUGH WHATEVER MEANS ARE MOST EFFECTIVE, INCLUDING EXPLOITING FEARS AND MORAL DISAGREEMENTS. SIMILARLY, THE EMPHASIS ON DIVISIVE ISSUES CAN ALSO SKEW POLICYMAKING. INSTEAD OF ADDRESSING A RANGE OF IMPORTANT TOPICS—ECONOMIC POLICIES, EDUCATION, HEALTHCARE—POLITICAL DISCOURSE MAY BECOME CONSUMED WITH A FEW POLARIZING ISSUES. THIS CAN LEAD TO POLICY GRIDLOCK AND A LACK OF PROGRESS IN KEY AREAS THAT AFFECT THE DAILY LIVES OF CITIZENS. ULTIMATELY, THIS STRATEGY CAN ALIENATE VAST SEGMENTS OF THE ELECTORATE WHO FEEL THAT THEIR COMPLEX VIEWS ARE NOT REPRESENTED. WHEN VOTERS PERCEIVE THAT NO PARTY OR CANDIDATE ADEQUATELY ADDRESSES THEIR DIVERSE CONCERNS, THEY MAY FEEL DISENFRANCHISED, LEADING TO DISENGAGEMENT FROM THE POLITICAL PROCESS, WHICH FURTHER DIMINISHES THE HEALTH OF DEMOCRATIC GOVERNANCE. WHILE USING POLARIZING ISSUES MIGHT OFFER SHORT-TERM ELECTORAL GAINS, THE LONG-TERM HEALTH OF A DEMOCRACY RELIES ON INFORMED, ENGAGED, AND NUANCED DISCOURSE. ENCOURAGING VOTERS TO LOOK BEYOND SINGLE-ISSUE DIMENSIONS AND CONSIDER COMPREHENSIVE PLATFORMS AND POLICIES CAN HELP MITIGATE THE DIVISIVE IMPACT OF THIS STRATEGY. FOR A HEALTHIER DEMOCRATIC PROCESS, BOTH POLITICIANS AND VOTERS MUST STRIVE FOR A MORE BALANCED AND INFORMED ENGAGEMENT, WHERE DIVERSE VIEWS CAN BE DEBATED RESPECTFULLY AND CONSTRUCTIVELY. THUS, AS WE EMBARK ON THIS DISCUSSION, THE MAIN ARGUMENT I WANT TO REMIND READERS OF BOILS DOWN TO ONE THING, WHICH ALL AMERICANS SHOULD BE ABLE TO AGREE ON ONCE YOU REMOVE THE PARTISAN GLASSES: RESTRICTIONS ON ABORTION RIGHTS CAN SET PRECEDENTS FOR LIMITING OTHER CONSTITUTIONAL RIGHTS, PARTICULARLY THOSE RELATED TO PERSONAL FREEDOMS AND PRIVACY. CONVERSELY, A STANCE THAT STRONGLY DEFENDS ABORTION RIGHTS AS A MATTER OF PERSONAL LIBERTY COULD REINFORCE PROTECTIONS AGAINST GOVERNMENTAL OVERREACH IN OTHER AREAS OF PRIVATE LIFE. IN PARTICULAR, THE ARIZONA LAW, WHICH ALLOWS ABORTIONS ONLY TO SAVE A WOMAN'S LIFE, TOUCHES ON PROFOUND ETHICAL QUESTIONS ABOUT THE SANCTITY OF LIFE AND THE AUTONOMY OF INDIVIDUALS. ADVOCATES FOR STRINGENT ABORTION LAWS OFTEN CITE MORAL CONVICTIONS ABOUT THE BEGINNING OF LIFE AND THE RIGHTS OF THE UNBORN, AND THEY VIEW ABORTION AS MURDER. CONVERSELY, OPPONENTS ARGUE FOR THE PRIMACY OF A WOMAN'S AUTONOMY OVER HER BODY AND HER LIFE CHOICES, VIEWING SUCH DECISIONS AS INTENSELY PERSONAL AND PRIVATE, GIVING HER FREEDOM OVER HER LIFE. THEY ARGUE THAT BY IMPOSING RESTRICTIVE LAWS ON ABORTION, THE GOVERNMENT IS OVERSTEPPING ITS BOUNDS. FUNDAMENTALLY, OUR NATION IS BUILT ON THE UNDERSTANDING THAT OUR INDIVIDUAL FREEDOM OF RELIGION IS SACRED. WHILE THE GOVERNMENT CANNOT ESTABLISH A RELIGION, THE INFLUENCE OF RELIGIOUS BELIEFS ON LAWS SUCH AS THOSE RESTRICTING ABORTION RAISES QUESTIONS ABOUT THE EXTENT TO WHICH SUCH LEGISLATION RESPECTS THIS PRINCIPLE. THE MORAL STAKES ARE IMMENSE WHEN SUCH RESTRICTIVE LEGISLATION CAN DICTATE THE TRAJECTORY OF A WOMAN'S LIFE.
A CALL TO ACTION FOR PRO-CHOICE ADVOCATES.
THE GRAPH PICTURED AVOVE FROM PEW RESEARCH (2024), UTILIZING DATA FROM THE GUTTMACHER INSTITUTE, IS NOT JUST A MERE REPRESENTATION OF NUMBERS—IT IS A STARK VISUAL NARRATIVE OF A TROUBLING REALITY. IT CHARTS A DECLINE THAT SPEAKS VOLUMES ABOUT THE STATE OF REPRODUCTIVE RIGHTS AND ACCESS IN THE UNITED STATES. THIS DECREASE SHOULD NOT BE SEEN AS A VICTORY FOR LIFE, AS SOME WOULD ARGUE, BUT AS A RED FLAG FOR THE RIGHTS AND HEALTH OF WOMEN. AS PROVIDERS DISAPPEAR, SO TOO DOES ACCESSIBLE, SAFE, AND LEGAL HEALTHCARE FOR COUNTLESS INDIVIDUALS WHO SEEK TO EXERCISE THEIR AUTONOMY OVER THEIR OWN BODIES. AS A CONSEQUENCE, THIS DISPARITY LEADS TO A PATCHWORK OF RIGHTS, WHERE A WOMAN'S ACCESS TO ABORTION—AND THUS HER RIGHT TO PRIVACY—CAN DEPEND LARGELY ON HER GEOGRAPHICAL LOCATION. THIS GEOGRAPHICAL INCONSISTENCY RAISES CRITICAL QUESTIONS ABOUT THE EQUALITY OF CONSTITUTIONAL PROTECTIONS ACROSS STATE LINES. SHOULDN'T FUNDAMENTAL RIGHTS, ESPECIALLY THOSE AS CRUCIAL AS PRIVACY AND PERSONAL LIBERTY, BE UNIFORMLY PROTECTED NATIONWIDE? THEREFORE, THE DOWNTREND IN THE NUMBER OF ABORTION PROVIDERS IS NOT A CAUSE FOR CELEBRATION BUT A CALL TO ACTION. SPECIFICALLY, THIS IS A CONSEQUENCE OF A TARGETED MORAL CRUSADE THAT HAS LITTLE TO DO WITH THE VALUE OF LIFE AND EVERYTHING TO DO WITH CONTROLLING WOMEN'S REPRODUCTIVE CHOICES. NOTABLY, THIS DOES NOT APPLY FOR SUPPORTERS OF ANTI-ABORTION LAWS, WHO TRULY BELIEVE ABORTION IS IMMORAL, BUT IT IS APPLICABLE TO UNDERSTAND THE STRATEGY AND THE GOALS OF THE POLITICIANS WHO ARE PROMOTING IT. ACCORDINGLY, IT STANDS AS EVIDENCE OF A MORALISTIC SIEGE THAT THREATENS THE VERY FABRIC OF A FREE AND JUST SOCIETY, AS IT UNDERMINES CITIZENS' RIGHTS IN MORE WAYS THAN MOST PEOPLE KNOW, AND THUS EFFECTIVELY GIVES THE GOVERNMENT MORE POWER.
SO LET'S UNDERSTAND THE CONTEXT-
WHAT IS THE LEGAL BASIS BEHIND ROE V. WADE, AND THUS THE PERSPECTIVE OF PRO-ABORTION ADVOCATES? THE RIGHT TO PRIVACY IN THE UNITED STATES, WHILE NOT EXPLICITLY MENTIONED IN THE CONSTITUTION, HAS BEEN INFERRED FROM SEVERAL AMENDMENTS AND HAS BEEN UPHELD BY NUMEROUS SUPREME COURT RULINGS. IN PARTICULAR, THE LEGAL DOCTRINE FOR THE RIGHT TO PRIVACY PRIMARILY STEMS FROM INTERPRETATIONS OF THE BILL OF RIGHTS AND SUBSEQUENT AMENDMENTS, WHICH OFFERED PROTECTION AGAINST UNWARRANTED GOVERNMENTAL INTRUSION STATE INTERFERENCE, AS SHOWN BELOW. THIS PRIMARILY HINGES ON THE DUE PROCESS CLAUSE OF THE FOURTEENTH AMENDMENT, WHICH HAS BEEN UNDERSTOOD TO PROTECT AGAINST UNWARRANTED STATE INTERFERENCE IN PERSONAL DECISIONS RELATED TO MARRIAGE, PROCREATION, AND FAMILY LIFE. THUS, THE RIGHT TO PRIVACY INCLUDED THE RIGHT FOR ONE TO MAKE THEIR OWN PERSONAL REPRODUCTIVE DECISIONS. View the infographic to see the key supreme court cases & Constitutional Amendments this stems from.
MOREOVER, THE APPLICATION OF THE RIGHT TO PRIVACY TO ABORTION WAS MOST SIGNIFICANTLY ADDRESSED IN ROE V. WADE (1973). THIS DECISION UNDERSCORED THAT THE RIGHT TO PRIVACY UNDER THE DUE PROCESS CLAUSE OF THE FOURTEENTH AMENDMENT EXTENDS TO A WOMAN'S DECISION TO HAVE AN ABORTION. ROE V. WADE ESTABLISHED THAT THIS RIGHT WAS FUNDAMENTAL TO A WOMAN’S "ZONE OF PRIVACY," A CONCEPT THAT INCLUDES BUT IS NOT LIMITED TO HER ABILITY TO DETERMINE WHETHER TO BEAR A CHILD. THOUGH THE DECISION HAS BEEN SUBJECT TO EXTENSIVE LEGAL AND POLITICAL CHALLENGES AND DEBATES, IT HIGHLIGHTED HOW DEEPLY EMBEDDED THE CONCEPT OF BODILY AUTONOMY AND PRIVACY RIGHTS ARE IN THE AMERICAN JUDICIAL ETHOS. THE RIGHT TO PRIVACY THUS SERVES AS A CRITICAL FOUNDATION FOR DEFENDING PERSONAL LIBERTY AGAINST UNDUE LEGISLATIVE OR EXECUTIVE PRESSURES.
THIS FRAMEWORK IS CENTRAL TO MODERN PRO-CHOICE ARGUMENTS WHICH ADVOCATE FOR THE PROTECTION OF INDIVIDUAL CHOICE, PARTICULARLY IN INTIMATE PERSONAL HEALTH DECISIONS, EMPHASIZING THAT NO SINGULAR RELIGIOUS VIEWPOINT SHOULD DICTATE UNIVERSAL LAWS IN A DIVERSE SOCIETY. MOREOVER, THIS DECISION EMPHASIZED THAT PERSONAL LIBERTY IS FUNDAMENTAL, NOTING THAT CHOICES INVOLVING THE BODY AND HEALTH ARE AMONG THE MOST PERSONAL AND IMPORTANT DECISIONS A PERSON CAN MAKE. THUS, IT REFLECTS A BROADER PHILOSOPHICAL COMMITMENT TO INDIVIDUAL AUTONOMY, A CORE PRINCIPLE IN LIBERAL DEMOCRACIES WHICH POSITS THAT INDIVIDUALS SHOULD HAVE THE FREEDOM TO MAKE DECISIONS ABOUT THEIR PERSONAL LIVES FREE FROM UNDUE GOVERNMENTAL INTERFERENCE. HOWEVER, ON JUNE 24, 2022, ROE V. WADE, THE LANDMARK DECISION THAT SECURED A WOMAN'S RIGHT TO ABORTION, WAS OVERTURNED BY THE SUPREME COURT IN THE DOBBS V. JACKSON WOMEN’S HEALTH ORGANIZATION CASE. WITH THE OVERTURNING, STATES REGAINED THE AUTHORITY TO SET THEIR ABORTION POLICIES, LEADING TO A PATCHWORK OF LAWS THAT REFLECT DIVERSE MORAL AND CULTURAL NORMS ACROSS THE COUNTRY. NOWADAYS, THE LANDSCAPE OF REPRODUCTIVE RIGHTS ACROSS THE UNITED STATES IS NOT A TAPESTRY BUT A CHECKERBOARD, WITH EACH STATE SETTING ITS OWN RULES, LEADING TO A STRIKING DISPARITY IN THE LEVEL OF PRIVACY AND FREEDOM AFFORDED TO ITS CITIZENS. THIS BEGS A PRESSING MORAL QUESTION: WHY SHOULD THE FUNDAMENTAL RIGHT TO PRIVACY AND PERSONAL LIBERTY VARY BY ZIP CODE? INDEED, CONSIDER HOW SOUTH CAROLINA HAS STIRRED A NATIONAL MAELSTROM BY CONTEMPLATING AND PROPOSING A LAW THAT WOULD CLASSIFY ABORTION AS HOMICIDE. HERE, AN UNTHINKABLE THOUGHT LINGERS - COULD WOMEN FACE THE DEATH PENALTY? ACCORDINGLY, THESE NEW MODERN ABORTION RESTRICTIONS, WHICH ARE OFTEN JUSTIFIED BY EARLY DETECTION OF FETAL HEARTBEATS OR MOVEMENTS, ARE INFRINGING ON THIS FUNDAMENTAL RIGHT TO HAVE LIMITED GOVERNMENT AND CONTROL OVER YOUR OWN BODY, AND THUS YOUR LIFE. FOR EXAMPLE, SUCH LAWS TYPICALLY SET GESTATIONAL LIMITS THAT ARE FAR EARLIER THAN MANY WOMEN EVEN REALIZE THEY ARE PREGNANT, EFFECTIVELY REMOVING THEIR FREEDOM TO CHOOSE BEFORE THEY HAVE A CHANCE TO EXERCISE IT. THIS ENCROACHMENT CAN LEAD TO SIGNIFICANT PERSONAL AND SOCIETAL REPERCUSSIONS. LOOK AT FLORIDA, WHERE AS OF NOW, IT ALLOWS LEGAL ABORTION UP TO A GESTATIONAL AGE OF 15 WEEKS. YET ON MAY 1, 2024, A SIGNIFICANT LEGISLATIVE SHIFT IS POISED TO TAKE EFFECT, TERMED THE "HEARTBEAT BILL," WHICH FLORIDA GOVERNOR RON DESANTIS SIGNED INTO LAW IN APRIL 2023. THIS CHANGE WILL PROHIBIT ABORTIONS ONCE AN EMBRYONIC OR FETAL HEARTBEAT CAN BE DETECTED, WHICH TYPICALLY OCCURS AROUND SIX WEEKS INTO A PREGNANCY, REFLECTING THE POINT AT WHICH MANY WOMEN DO NOT EVEN REALIZE THEY ARE PREGNANT. HOWEVER, PROBLEMATICALLY, MOST MEDICAL EXPERTS ARGUE THAT THESE EARLY SIGNS DO NOT REPRESENT A VIABLE, SENTIENT LIFE BUT ARE SIMPLY PART OF THE DEVELOPMENTAL PROCESS. POLITICIZING SUCH SCIENTIFIC MILESTONES RISKS TURNING MEDICINE INTO A POLITICAL WEAPON, AIMED AT CURTAILING RIGHTS RATHER THAN FOSTERING INFORMED ETHICAL DISCUSSIONS. FURTHERMORE, THE RECENT RULING BY THE ARIZONA SUPREME COURT, WHICH REINSTATES A NEARLY COMPLETE BAN ON ABORTIONS STEMMING FROM A PRE-STATEHOOD LAW DATING BACK TO 1864, BRINGS FORTH MORE QUESTIONS, AS THE RULING ALLOWS FOR AN ABORTION ONLY WHEN THE MOTHER'S LIFE IS AT RISK, WITHOUT OFFERING ANY EXCEPTIONS FOR RAPE OR INCEST. THUS, IF OUR CONSTITUTION GUARANTEES US THE RIGHT TO PRIVACY AND THE RIGHT TO BE FREE FROM GOVERNMENT INTRUSION IN OUR PERSONAL LIVES, AS AMERICANS, ARE WE NOT WITNESSING A VIOLATION OF THIS SACRED RIGHT? IS THE GOVERNMENT NOT ENCROACHING UPON THE PERSONAL AND INTIMATE DECISIONS OF WOMEN ACROSS OUR NATION? MOREOVER, WHY ARE STATES ALLOWED TO DIFFER IN THEIR INTERPRETATIONS OF WHAT LEVEL INVOLVEMENT THEY CAN HAVE ON THE MOST PERSONAL DECISION ONE CAN MAKE? IN STATES LIKE CALIFORNIA, WHERE ABORTION LAWS ARE MORE PERMISSIVE, RESIDENTS ARGUABLY ENJOY GREATER PRIVACY AND PERSONAL LIBERTY IN MAKING DECISIONS ABOUT THEIR REPRODUCTIVE HEALTH. CONVERSELY, IN STATES LIKE FLORIDA AND ARIZONA, WHERE STRICTER ABORTION LAWS PREVAIL, THE LEVEL OF GOVERNMENT INTRUSION INTO PERSONAL DECISIONS IS MARKEDLY HIGHER. THUS, ARE CITIZENS IN CALIFORNIA AFFORDED MORE PRIVACY, PERSONAL LIBERTY, FREEDOM, AND PROTECTIONS SAFEGUARDING GOVERNMENT OVERREACH THAN CITIZENS FROM FLORIDA AND ARIZONA? THE DATA FROM PEW RESEARCH SHINES A LIGHT ON THE CONSEQUENCE OF THIS VARIABILITY: WOMEN ARE OFTEN FORCED TO CROSS STATE LINES TO ACCESS ABORTION SERVICES, TURNING WHAT SHOULD BE A PRIVATE MEDICAL DECISION INTO A LOGISTICAL AND SOMETIMES PUBLIC ORDEAL. FOR EXAMPLE, IN 2O21, 10.9% OF ALL ABORTIONS WERE PERFORMED ON WOMEN WHO LIVED OUTSIDE THE STATE WHERE THE ABORTION OCCURRED. THIS IS A SLIGHT INCREASE FROM 2020, WHEN THE PERCENTAGE WAS 9.7%. MOREOVER, HISTORICALLY, THE PERCENTAGE OF ABORTIONS OBTAINED BY WOMEN FROM DIFFERENT STATES WAS SIGNIFICANTLY HIGHER PRIOR TO THE 1973 SUPREME COURT DECISION IN ROE V. WADE. IN 1972, A SUBSTANTIAL 41% OF ALL ABORTIONS ACCORDING TO THE STATES THAT WERE REPORTING DATA WERE PERFORMED ON NON-RESIDENT WOMEN. BY 1973, THIS FIGURE DROPPED TO 21%, AND FURTHER DECREASED TO 11% BY 1974. THE FIGURES TELL A STORY OF A NATION WHERE, BEFORE ROE V. WADE, WOMEN TRAVELED FAR FROM HOME TO CLAIM A RIGHT THAT SHOULD HAVE BEEN ACCESSIBLE IN THEIR OWN BACKYARDS—A PHENOMENON THAT WE ARE STARTING TO SEE REEMERGE. THIS WITHDRAWAL OF RIGHTS NOT ONLY CHALLENGES THE CONCEPT OF EQUALITY BEFORE THE LAW BUT ALSO EXPOSES A DANGEROUS PRECEDENT WHERE PERSONAL FREEDOMS ARE SUBJECT TO POLITICAL WHIMS. IT'S A SITUATION THAT NOT ONLY IMPACTS THE RIGHT TO AN ABORTION BUT EXTENDS TO OTHER REALMS OF PERSONAL AUTONOMY, SUCH AS THE ABILITY TO DIVORCE DURING PREGNANCY, DISCUSSED NEXT. NEXT, I PROCEED WITH A DISCUSSION OF ISSUES SURROUNDING GETTING A DIVORCE DURING PREGNANCY. AS WE DELVE INTO THE ISSUES SURROUNDING DIVORCE DURING PREGNANCY, IT BECOMES INCREASINGLY CLEAR THAT THE STRUGGLE FOR AUTONOMY AND PRIVACY IS FAR FROM OVER. IT IS A STRUGGLE THAT DEMANDS OUR MORAL VIGILANCE AND OUR UNWAVERING COMMITMENT TO ENSURING THAT PERSONAL LIBERTY REMAINS PROTECTED FROM SEA TO SHINING SEA.
THE INTERSECTION OF DIVORCE, PREGNANCY, AND PRIVACY RIGHTS IN MISSOURI, TEXAS, AND ARKANSAS.
THE RESTRICTIONS THAT PREVENT FINALIZING DIVORCES DURING PREGNANCY IN STATES LIKE MISSOURI, TEXAS, AND ARKANSAS UNDERSCORE A COORDINATED EFFORT BY POLITICAL FORCES TO CURTAIL PRIVACY. THEY SERVE AS STARK EXAMPLES OF HOW LAWS CAN INTRUDE UPON THE MOST INTIMATE DECISIONS, HIGHLIGHTING AN ONGOING BATTLE FOR PERSONAL LIBERTIES AGAINST THE EXPANDING REACH OF GOVERNMENT POWER. THESE LAWS AIM TO ENSURE THAT ISSUES RELATED TO CHILD CUSTODY AND SUPPORT ARE RESOLVED BEFORE THE DISSOLUTION OF MARRIAGE IS OFFICIALLY DECREED. PROPONENTS ARGUE THAT THESE LAWS ARE DESIGNED TO PROVIDE FINANCIAL STABILITY AND SECURE ARRANGEMENTS FOR THE UNBORN CHILD. CONVERSELY, CRITICS ARGUE THESE LAWS TRAP PREGNANT INDIVIDUALS IN POTENTIALLY HARMFUL DOMESTIC SITUATIONS, EXACERBATING RISKS AND INFRINGING ON THEIR PRIVACY AND AUTONOMY. FOR EXAMPLE, THE LATTER ARGUMENT IS SUPPORTED BY ALARMING RESEARCH FROM HARVARD T.H. CHAN SCHOOL OF PUBLIC HEALTH REVEALS THAT HOMICIDE IS A LEADING CAUSE OF DEATH AMONG PREGNANT WOMEN IN THE U.S., OFTEN LINKED TO INTIMATE PARTNER VIOLENCE EXACERBATED BY LENIENT FIREARMS LEGISLATION. THIS ADDS ANOTHER LAYER OF URGENCY TO THESE DISCUSSIONS, EMPHASIZING THE LIFE-AND-DEATH CONSEQUENCES OF FAILING TO PROTECT THOSE MOST VULNERABLE, AND THUS RAISES CRITICAL QUESTIONS ABOUT THE BALANCE OF STATE INTERESTS AGAINST INDIVIDUAL RIGHTS. ACCORDINGLY, WHAT WE'RE SEEING IS A SYSTEMATIC EROSION OF THE RIGHT TO PRIVACY THAT WAS SO ROBUSTLY DEFENDED BY ROE V. WADE. THIS RIGHT IS BEING ERODED IN BROAD DAYLIGHT, CLOAKED IN THE LANGUAGE OF LIFE BUT STRIKING AT THE HEART OF LIBERTY. TO STAND IDLY BY AS THIS OCCURS IS TO BE COMPLICIT IN THE ROLLBACK OF THE HARD-WON FREEDOMS THAT MANY HAVE FOUGHT FOR OVER DECADES. GIVEN THESE CONSIDERATIONS, PERHAPS THE TERMS OF THE DEBATE AROUND ABORTION NEED REFRAMING. INSTEAD OF "PRO-CHOICE" VS. "PRO-LIFE," WE MIGHT CONSIDER "PRO-PRIVACY" VS. "ANTI-PRIVACY" AS A MORE ACCURATE DICHOTOMY, EMPHASIZING THE IMPORTANCE OF UPHOLDING CONSTITUTIONAL RIGHTS AND PERSONAL FREEDOMS ACROSS ALL STATES. THIS FRAMING SHIFTS THE FOCUS FROM THE MORALITY OF ABORTION TO THE PRINCIPLE OF INDIVIDUAL LIBERTY AND PRIVACY, AND EMPHASIZES THE ROLE OF THE GOVERNMENT IN SAFEGUARDING—OR FAILING TO SAFEGUARD. THUS, THIS INTERSECTION OF PRIVACY RIGHTS, ESPECIALLY CONCERNING PERSONAL RELATIONSHIPS AND FAMILY LIFE WITHOUT UNDUE GOVERNMENT INTERFERENCE, ILLUSTRATES POTENTIAL OVERREACH AND HIGHLIGHTS THE PRESSING NEED FOR PROTECTIVE MEASURES THAT ALIGN WITH THE CHERISHED VALUES OF PERSONAL FREEDOM AND PRIVACY. THESE DISCUSSIONS ARE ESSENTIAL NOT ONLY FOR THOSE DIRECTLY AFFECTED BUT FOR ANYONE CONCERNED WITH THE BROADER IMPLICATIONS OF PRIVACY RIGHTS IN OUR SOCIETY. THIS IS FURTHER ELABORATED ON IN THE NEXT SECTION, WHERE WE WILL DISCUSS HOW SUCH STRINGENT RESTRICTIONS ON WOMEN'S PERSONAL LIBERTY AND RIGHT TO PRIVACY ALSO RAISE CRITICAL QUESTIONS ABOUT THE INFLUENCE OF RELIGIOUS AND MORAL BELIEFS ON SECULAR LAWS.
LET US BREAK IT DOWN FURTHER: the influence of religion
(NOTE: IN A SUBSEQUENT SECTION termed, 'the argument against roe. v wade', there IS AN ANALYSIS THAT DELVES DEEPER INTO THE COMPLEX AND NUANCED RELATIONSHIP BETWEEN CHRISTIANITY, RELIGIOUS BELIEFS, AND THE VIEW OF ABORTION AS MURDER, EXPLORING SOME HISTORICAL CONTEXT, THEOLOGICAL DEBATES, AND THE DIFFERING VIEWS WITHIN CHRISTIANITY ITSELF). AS WE DEBATE THESE ISSUES, IT'S CRUCIAL TO REMEMBER THAT AT THE HEART OF THE ABORTION DEBATE IS THE BROADER ISSUE OF INDIVIDUAL RIGHTS AND FREEDOMS. DESPITE THIS, THE DRIVING FACTOR OF THE CONTROVERSY IS THE FACT THAT MANY OF OUR FELLOW CITIZENS VIEW THIS ISSUE THROUGH THE LENS OF THEIR FAITH. FOR INSTANCE, MANY SUPPORTERS OF RESTRICTIVE ABORTION LAWS MAY CITE THEIR RELIGIOUS BELIEFS AS A JUSTIFICATION FOR THEIR POSITION, ARGUING THAT LIFE BEGINS AT CONCEPTION, A VIEW SUPPORTED BY SEVERAL RELIGIOUS TRADITIONS. THUS, THE ETHICAL DEBATE OVER ABORTION IS DEEPLY ROOTED IN DIFFERING BELIEFS ABOUT THE SANCTITY OF LIFE AND INDIVIDUAL AUTONOMY. BUT, THIS IS WHERE THE LINES BLUR. WHEN INDIVIDUALS' RELIGIOUS VIEWS IMPACT A GOVERNMENTAL DECISION AND REQUIRE THEM TO RESTRICT CONSTITUTIONAL RIGHTS, WE START TO QUESTION: DOES BANNING ABORTION ON THE BASIS OF A RELIGIOUS BELIEF, NOT MAKE THE LAW A RELIGIOUS MATTER? WHEN LAWS ENTWINE WITH RELIGIOUS DOCTRINE, THE BOUNDARY BETWEEN PERSONAL BELIEF AND PUBLIC POLICY DOESN'T JUST BLUR—IT VANISHES.
THE SLIPPERY SLOPE OF RELIGIOUS INFLUENCE IN LAW.
IN LIBERAL DEMOCRACIES, THE PRINCIPLE OF SEPARATION BETWEEN CHURCH AND STATE IS FOUNDATIONAL TO PROTECTING THE RIGHTS OF INDIVIDUALS TO PRACTICE THEIR RELIGION FREELY, WITHOUT IMPOSING THOSE PRACTICES ON OTHERS WHO MIGHT HAVE DIFFERENT BELIEFS. CONVERSELY, IN MANY COUNTRIES WHERE GOVERNMENT AND RELIGIOUS BELIEFS ARE DEEPLY INTERTWINED, LAWS OFTEN REFLECT SPECIFIC RELIGIOUS DOCTRINES, WHICH CAN RESTRICT PERSONAL FREEDOMS. FOR INSTANCE, IN SOME ISLAMIC COUNTRIES, SHARIA LAW INFLUENCES MANY ASPECTS OF PUBLIC POLICY, FROM DRESS CODES REQUIRING WOMEN TO WEAR HEADSCARVES TO STRINGENT PENALTIES FOR BEHAVIORS DEEMED UN-ISLAMIC, which ALIGNs WITH THE MAJORITY RELIGIOUS BELIEFS IN THOSE COUNTRIES. APPLYING THE SAME CONCERN TO THE UNITED STATES, IF A GOVERNMENT RESTRICTS A WOMAN'S CONTROL OVER HER OWN BODY IN THE NAME OF RELIGIOUS BELIEF:
Furthermore, to predicate the legality of abortion on religious morality is to disregard the multiplicity of ethical perspectives that inform this deeply complex issue. specifically, It fails to acknowledge the spectrum of views on when life begins, which vary not only across different religions but also within them, and completely ignores the non-religious but equally ethical stances many individuals hold. FOR EXAMPLE, when we LEGISLATE AGAINST ABORTION STRICTLY FROM A CHRISTIAN PERSPECTIVE, THIS may ALIENATE AND OPPRESS THOSE WHO DO NOT SHARE THE SAME BELIEFS, INCLUDING ATHEISTS, AGNOSTICS, AND ADHERENTS OF OTHER RELIGIONS. THUS, JUST AS MANY IN THE U.S. WOULD FIND IT UNACCEPTABLE FOR ISLAMIC PRINCIPLES TO DICTATE PUBLIC POLICIES, SO TOO COULD SIMILAR APPLICATIONS OF CHRISTIAN DOCTRINES BE SEEN AS EQUALLY PROBLEMATIC. EXAMPLES FROM HISTORY OFTEN PROVIDE CONTEXT TO HOW THIS CAN BECOME CONCERNING. HISTORICALLY, RELIGIOUS DOCTRINES HAVE INFLUENCED LAWS CONCERNING CONTRACEPTION AND DIVORCE, REFLECTING DOMINANT CHRISTIAN NORMS AT THE TIME. FOR INSTANCE, UP UNTIL THE MID-20TH CENTURY, MANY U.S. STATES HAD LAWS THAT PROHIBITED THE SALE AND USE OF CONTRACEPTIVES, INFLUENCED LARGELY BY RELIGIOUS VIEWS ON BIRTH CONTROL. SIMILARLY, DIVORCE LAWS WERE ONCE STRINGENT, REFLECTING THE CHRISTIAN BELIEF IN THE SANCTITY OF MARRIAGE. AS SOCIETAL VALUES SHIFTED TOWARDS GREATER PERSONAL FREEDOM, THESE LAWS WERE SEEN AS INTRUSIVE AND OUTDATED, LEADING TO THEIR REFORM, AT LEAST TEMPORARILY. NOW, IF WE RECONSIDER OUR DISCUSSION ON HOW STATES ARE RESTRICTING THE RIGHT TO DIVORCE DURING PREGNANCY, THEN IT BECOMES CLEAR THAT WE FACE A RESURGENCE OF THIS DOGMATIC APPROACH. INDEED, IN THE INTRICATE DANCE OF LAW AND PERSONAL LIBERTY, STATE RESTRICTIONS ON DIVORCE DURING PREGNANCY RESONATE WITH THE SAME DISSONANCE THAT PLAGUES THE ABORTION DEBATE. THESE DIVORCE LAWS, MUCH LIKE THE VARIED ABORTION LAWS POST-ROE, REFLECT AN UNDERLYING ASSUMPTION: THAT THE STATE KNOWS BEST WHEN IT COMES TO THE MOST INTIMATE ASPECTS OF LIFE—BE IT A WOMAN'S MARRIAGE OR HER BODY. THIS IS A PATRIARCHAL OVERTURE, CONDUCTED OFTEN UNDER THE GUISE OF RELIGIOUS MORALITY, THAT IGNORES THE DIVERSE ETHICAL SYMPHONY THAT COMPOSES OUR SOCIETY. THUS, THE LEGISLATIVE ZEAL TO IMPOSE SUCH RESTRICTIONS UNDER THIS GUISE ESSENTIALLY SERVES TO UNDERMINE WOMEN'S RIGHTS. INDEED, LET US NOT FORGET THAT THE RIGHT TO AN ABORTION HAS THE ABILITY TO COMMAND A WOMAN'S FUTURE, HER LIFE CHOICES, AND HER BODILY AUTONOMY. THUS, TO ANCHOR THE RIGHT TO CHOOSE OR THE RIGHT TO DIVORCE DURING PREGNANCY IN RELIGIOUS DOGMA IS TO NEGLECT THE PLURALISM THAT DEFINES US, PRECISELY WHAT THE FRAMERS OF THE CONSTITUTION SOUGHT TO AVOID BY ESTABLISHING THE SEPARATION OF CHURCH AND STATE. SPECIFICALLY, THIS ANTI-PRIVACY AND ANTI-FIRST AMENDMENT LEGISLATION BEING PASSED POST-ROE, ENCROACHES ON THE PRIVATE SPHERE, CONTRAVENING THE CONSTITUTIONAL SHIELD OF PRIVACY AND FREEDOM FROM GOVERNMENTAL OVERREACH. IT'S A STANCE THAT COULD COMPEL WOMEN TO REMAIN IN UNWANTED MARRIAGES OR CARRY PREGNANCIES TO TERM AGAINST THEIR WILL, DISPROPORTIONATELY HARMING THOSE ALREADY MARGINALIZED BY ECONOMIC AND RACIAL INEQUITIES. ULTIMATELY, THIS IS A TROUBLING ECHO OF A TIME WHEN CONTRACEPTION AND DIVORCE WERE BOUND BY THE CHAINS OF RELIGIOUS DOCTRINE, CURTAILING FREEDOMS UNDER THE GUISE OF UPHOLDING SANCTITY. THUS, ALTHOUGH POLITICIANS TRY TO DISTRACT US, AND THEY USE THESE HEATED ISSUES TO DIVIDE US, I MUST REITERATE THAT POLITICIANS ARE NOT HERE TO EDUCATE, THEY ARE HERE TO WIN, AND THE MORE DIVIDED WE ARE, THE MORE POWER THEY HAVE. IN ORDER TO 'DROWN THE SWAMP' AND MAKE POLITICIANS ACCOUNTABLE, WE MUST STOP ARGUING OVER INDIVIDUALS' RELIGIOUS BELIEFS, AND FOCUS ON THE PRINCIPLES THAT MADE AMERICA AND BUILT OUR NATION. IN ORDER TO DO THIS, WE MUST PROTECT THE VARIETY OF RELIGIOUS AND NON-RELIGIOUS BELIEFS, AND WE MUST PREVENT OUR LAWS FROM BEING INFLUENCED BY THEM.
HOW HAS ABORTION POLICY CHANGED IN THE USA OVER THE YEARS?
INTERESTINGLY, IN THE COLONIAL AMERICAN PERIOD, ABORTION WAS A COMMON PRACTICE AND WAS GENERALLY PERMISSIBLE UNTIL "QUICKENING" — THE MOMENT WHEN FETAL MOVEMENTS ARE FIRST FELT BY THE PREGNANT WOMAN, WHICH IS TYPICALLY BETWEEN THE FOURTH AND SIXTH MONTH OF PREGNANCY. DURING THIS ERA, ABORTION WAS GOVERNED MORE BY SOCIAL AND MORAL NORMS THAN BY LAW. HOWEVER, THIS IS ALSO TIED TO ITS RELIGION, AS DISCUSSED IN THE ANTI-ABORTION PERSPECTIVE SECTION THAT FOLLOWS. FOR A QUICK SUMMARY, SAINT AUGUSTINE, WHO CONTRIBUTED TO THE DISCOURSE ON ABORTION WITH HIS THOUGHTS ON "ENSOULMENT," SPECULATED ABOUT THE STAGE AT WHICH THE SOUL ENTERS THE BODY, WHICH INFLUENCED LATER MEDIEVAL DEBATES ABOUT "QUICKENING." FOLLOWING THIS, THE 19TH CENTURY MARKED A SIGNIFICANT SHIFT IN THE PERCEPTION AND LEGALITY OF ABORTION. WITH THE RISE OF THE AMERICAN MEDICAL ASSOCIATION IN 1847, PHYSICIANS BEGAN TO LOBBY AGAINST ABORTION, ARGUING IT WAS BOTH IMMORAL AND DANGEROUS. BY THE END OF THE CENTURY, MOST STATES HAD LAWS ON THE BOOKS THAT BANNED ABORTION, WITH EXCEPTIONS MADE ONLY WHEN THE MOTHER'S LIFE WAS AT RISK--> THIS IS THE ERA THAT THE ARIZONA RULING STEMS FROM. THIS ERA SAW THE MEDICALIZATION OF CHILDBIRTH AND GYNECOLOGY, WITH MALE DOCTORS PUSHING MIDWIVES AND OTHER FEMALE PRACTITIONERS OUT OF THE FIELD, THEREBY CONSOLIDATING THE CONTROL OF MEN OVER WOMEN'S REPRODUCTIVE HEALTH. IN 1873, THE COMSTOCK LAWS WERE ENACTED, PROHIBITING THE DISSEMINATION OF ANY "OBSCENE, LEWD, OR LASCIVIOUS" MATERIAL, WHICH INCLUDED ANY INFORMATION ON ABORTION AND CONTRACEPTION. THIS LED TO A DARK PERIOD WHERE WOMEN SEEKING ABORTIONS HAD TO RESORT TO UNSAFE, ILLICIT PROCEDURES. THE TERM "BACK-ALLEY ABORTIONS" BECAME SYNONYMOUS WITH THE DANGEROUS AND OFTEN DEADLY METHODS EMPLOYED DURING THESE TIMES. LATER, THE 1960S AND 1970S BROUGHT A SURGE OF ADVOCACY FOR WOMEN'S RIGHTS, INCLUDING REPRODUCTIVE RIGHTS. THE FEMINIST MOVEMENT, ALONG WITH CHANGES IN PUBLIC OPINION, PAVED THE WAY FOR LEGISLATIVE REFORM. IN 1973, THE LANDMARK SUPREME COURT CASE ROE V. WADE LEGALIZED ABORTION NATIONWIDE. THIS DECISION MANDATED THAT STATES COULD NOT BAN ABORTION BEFORE VIABILITY (THE POINT AT WHICH A FETUS CAN SURVIVE OUTSIDE THE WOMB), WHICH IS GENERALLY AROUND 24 WEEKS. HOWEVER, DESPITE ROE V. WADE, ABORTION REMAINED A DEEPLY DIVISIVE ISSUE. IN 1976, THE HYDE AMENDMENT WAS PASSED, BARRING THE USE OF FEDERAL FUNDS FOR ABORTIONS EXCEPT IN CASES OF RAPE, INCEST, OR WHEN THE LIFE OF THE MOTHER IS AT RISK. THIS AMENDMENT SIGNIFICANTLY AFFECTED LOW INCOME WOMEN WHO RELY ON GOVERNMENT HEALTH INSURANCE LIKE MEDICAID. SIMULTANEOUSLY, IN THE EARLY 1970S, FOLLOWING THE LANDMARK ROE V. WADE DECISION, ABORTION WAS NOT A SHARPLY PARTISAN ISSUE. BOTH THE DEMOCRATIC AND REPUBLICAN PARTIES HAD MEMBERS WHO SUPPORTED AND OPPOSED ABORTION RIGHTS. NOTABLY, THE DECISION ITSELF WAS DELIVERED BY A SUPREME COURT DOMINATED BY JUSTICES APPOINTED BY REPUBLICAN PRESIDENTS. JUSTICE HARRY BLACKMUN, WHO WROTE THE MAJORITY OPINION IN ROE, WAS APPOINTED BY REPUBLICAN PRESIDENT RICHARD NIXON.
WHY IS ABORTION ASSOCIATED WITH POLITICAL PARTIES, AND HAS IT ALWAYS BEEN LIKE THIS?
ACCORDINGLY, THE ASSOCIATION OF ANTI-ABORTION STANCES WITH THE REPUBLICAN PARTY AND PRO-CHOICE STANCES WITH THE DEMOCRATIC PARTY IS A RELATIVELY RECENT DEVELOPMENT IN THE CONTEXT OF AMERICAN POLITICAL HISTORY. THE PIVOTAL CHANGE IN THE REPUBLICAN PARTY’S STANCE ON ABORTION BEGAN WITH THE RISE OF THE RELIGIOUS RIGHT IN THE LATE 1970S AND EARLY 1980S. THIS MOVEMENT, WHICH INCLUDED INFLUENTIAL EVANGELICAL AND CONSERVATIVE CHRISTIAN GROUPS, SOUGHT TO ALIGN ITSELF WITH POLITICAL ENTITIES THAT WOULD SUPPORT ITS MORAL AND SOCIAL AGENDAS, WHICH INCLUDED OPPOSITION TO ABORTION. THE 1980 PRESIDENTIAL ELECTION MARKED A SIGNIFICANT TURNING POINT WHEN RONALD REAGAN, A REPUBLICAN, COURTED THE RELIGIOUS RIGHT AND OPENLY SUPPORTED PRO-LIFE POSITIONS, CONTRASTING WITH EARLIER REPUBLICAN PLATFORMS WHICH HAD EITHER SUPPORTED ABORTION RIGHTS OR MAINTAINED NEUTRALITY. THE FORMATION OF THE MORAL MAJORITY BY JERRY FALWELL IN 1979 WAS INSTRUMENTAL IN REDEFINING THE REPUBLICAN STANCE ON ABORTION. THIS GROUP, AND OTHERS LIKE IT, PLAYED A CRITICAL ROLE IN MOBILIZING CONSERVATIVE CHRISTIANS AS A KEY VOTER BASE FOR THE REPUBLICAN PARTY. THEIR INFLUENCE TRANSFORMED ABORTION FROM A MEDICAL AND SOCIAL ISSUE INTO A MORAL AND RELIGIOUS CRUSADE, EMBEDDING IT INTO THE REPUBLICAN PLATFORM AS A NON-NEGOTIABLE ISSUE. BY THE TIME OF THE 1980S, THE REPUBLICAN PARTY HAD OFFICIALLY ADOPTED A PRO-LIFE POSITION, WHICH WAS CEMENTED INTO ITS PLATFORM AND HAS REMAINED A STAPLE EVER SINCE. AS REPUBLICANS MOVED TO THE RIGHT ON ABORTION, THE DEMOCRATIC PARTY SIMULTANEOUSLY SHIFTED TO A MORE CONSISTENTLY PRO-CHOICE POSITION. THIS SHIFT WAS PARTIALLY IN RESPONSE TO THE ADVOCACY WITHIN THE PARTY BY FEMINIST GROUPS AND OTHER SOCIAL MOVEMENTS THAT EMPHASIZED WOMEN'S RIGHTS AND AUTONOMY. OVER THE DECADES, AS THE RELIGIOUS RIGHT SOLIDIFIED ITS HOLD OVER THE REPUBLICAN PARTY, DEMOCRATS INCREASINGLY EMBRACED ABORTION RIGHTS AS PART OF A BROADER HUMAN RIGHTS AND SOCIAL JUSTICE AGENDA. THROUGHOUT THE 1990S AND INTO THE 21ST CENTURY, ABORTION INCREASINGLY BECAME A CENTRAL ISSUE IN THE BROADER "CULTURE WARS" THAT DEFINED MUCH OF AMERICAN POLITICS. MEDIA PORTRAYAL OF THE ISSUE, AS WELL AS LOBBYING AND ACTIVISM BY GROUPS ON BOTH SIDES OF THE DEBATE, FURTHER POLARIZED PUBLIC OPINION AND POLITICAL PARTIES. TODAY, POSITIONS ON ABORTION OFTEN SERVE AS A LITMUS TEST FOR CANDIDATES IN BOTH PARTIES, A FAR CRY FROM THE MORE MIXED POSITIONS OF EARLIER DECADES. RECENT DEVELOPMENTS WITH THE JUDICIAL LANDSCAPE CHANGING UNDER RECENT REPUBLICAN PRESIDENCIES, CULMINATING IN THE OVERTURNING OF ROE V. WADE BY A CONSERVATIVE-MAJORITY SUPREME COURT IN 2022, THE REPUBLICAN PARTY'S COMMITMENT TO RESTRICTING ABORTION HAS ACHIEVED SIGNIFICANT JUDICIAL BACKING, REFLECTING THE LONG-TERM IMPACT OF THE PARTY'S ALIGNMENT WITH ANTI-ABORTION STANCES. AS THIS ISSUE BECOMES CENTRAL TO THE UPCOMING ELECTORAL DEBATES, IT IS IMPERATIVE TO RECOGNIZE AND CONFRONT THE BROADER IMPLICATIONS OF SUCH LEGAL ACTIONS. THEY NOT ONLY REFLECT ON ABORTION RIGHTS BUT ALSO CHALLENGE THE VERY ESSENCE OF INDIVIDUAL LIBERTY AND THE SECULAR FOUNDATION OF AMERICAN LAW AS ESTABLISHED BY THE FIRST AMENDMENT. THE BATTLE OVER ABORTION RIGHTS IN ARIZONA AND ACROSS THE UNITED STATES IS NOT MERELY A LEGAL OR POLITICAL ISSUE; IT IS A PROFOUND STRUGGLE FOR THE SOUL OF AMERICA, TESTING OUR COMMITMENT TO THOSE PRINCIPLES OF FREEDOM AND SEPARATION OF CHURCH AND STATE THAT DEFINES OUR DEMOCRACY. THE ANTI-ABORTION PERSPECTIVE:AN INVESTIGATION INTO THE ARGUMENT AGAINST ROE V. WADE
|
Archives
July 2025
AuthorAvee Allgood
This website uses marketing and tracking technologies. Opting out of this will opt you out of all cookies, except for those needed to run the website. Note that some products may not work as well without tracking cookies. Opt Out of Cookies |


RSS Feed